Quantcast
Channel: Comments on: The best and worst orchestras of 2012 – your vote, please
Browsing all 46 articles
Browse latest View live

By: Norman Lebrecht

It’s tricky, Tito. Playisg aside, they’ve made a dog’s dinner of Baden-Baden and triumphed with the Sony tech deal. A very mixed year for Berlin.

View Article



By: Norman Lebrecht

Read the criteria before you leap to judgement.

View Article

By: GPehli

Best: Berlin Philharmonic. An all-road orchestra, delivering the best playing possible and now making an amazing effort to reach new audiences through community concerts, broadcasting concerts a la...

View Article

By: Larry Tucker

What is the point of this? Is there truly a best and worst orchestra? Is it not more important how an orchestra serves it’s community?

View Article

By: franz

Agree on both counts, Pierre. Love what Berlin is doing with Digital Concert Hall, with the great free pre-concert interviews online, They’re opening up their performances to the world in much the same...

View Article


By: Tito Munoz

I suppose it’s fair to say that time will tell regarding Salzburg/Baden-Baden, no? As insolent as it may have been or appeared, these kinds of things can certainly take a life of their own after the...

View Article

By: Rgiarola

Realist, Orchestras and managers as an enterprise. If it was not the criteria, I would not vote on LA Philharmonic and Borda. This kind of thing it is not necessary to be on-the-spot to analyzed, as...

View Article

By: Rgiarola

Mr. Norman, also I haven’t seem Berliner as the news headlines as it was used to be. It is also a fact that can affect deeply the brand. On the other hand, they decreased the risk level for backlash...

View Article


By: Christophe

I find these comments unfair. I am an orchestra musician, but I can say without a doubt that some orchestras play badly, regardless of the quality of a conductor, because sometimes mediocre musicians...

View Article


By: Norman Lebrecht

Exactly, Christophe. I could not agree more.

View Article

By: Anon

Or has management been put in a difficult position by players demanding salaries that are not commensurate with the audiences they are pulling in?

View Article

By: Robert Fitzpatrick

I forgot about this interview, a truly seminal moment in the history of western art music. I do feel that the maestro was toying with an easy prey and might have been showing a slightly condescending...

View Article

By: Robert Fitzpatrick

I disagree. That’s desperate management that has ignored its fiduciary responsibilty for decades and then used corporate tactics to fix specific problems which could have been solved by honest...

View Article


By: Pamela Brown

@Anon said, “Or has management been put in a difficult position by players demanding salaries that are not commensurate with the audiences they are pulling in?” I might have thought that at the start...

View Article

By: Robert Fitzpatrick

Sorry, my sarcasm is showing. Certainly there are mainly fine regional orchestras in the USA. They tend to be rather stable and dedicated to serving their community or region. Allentown is a area...

View Article


By: Chip Michael

While I have a bias, TwtrSymphony should certainly be listed as an up and coming orchestra, one to watch in 2013! http://TwtrSymphony.instantencore.com

View Article

By: george brown

I think it would be FAR more accurate to say that in America, it has been the worst year for orchestra governance and administration since the depression.

View Article


By: Larry Tucker

I still feel the same. First, no one knows all of the orchestras around the world. It is subjective, and impact on the community is also quite subjective.

View Article

By: Taron Cochrane

BEST: The Regina Symphony Orchestra. Proudly celebrating their 104th year (and currently Canada’s longest continuously performing Orchestra) 2012 saw them break new ground with completely unique and...

View Article

By: Garrett McQueen

I whole heartedly agree with your issue with the term authentic.

View Article
Browsing all 46 articles
Browse latest View live




Latest Images